Gifting

Your guide to anniversaries & milestone years: the best natural diamond jewelry to celebrate love 

For those occasions when a box of chocolates just won’t cut it, we’ve got you covered with the very best and most dazzling alternatives

Bianca Hartel | 7 min read
Published: December 10, 2025 | Last updated: December 10, 2025
Batch 9 61  Anniversaries milestone years  The best natural diamond jewelry to celebrate love Lead Image 1600 x 675px

Anniversaries are the treasured chapters in a love story still being written. From that first heady year of newlywed bliss to the joyful milestones that follow every year after, each anniversary offers an opportunity to pause and look back on those moments passed together, along with what you’ve achieved and celebrated as a couple. For each of those years, marking the moment is important, and what gift could convey love better than natural diamond jewelry? 

Formed over billions of years deep within the earth, natural diamond formation is often said to mirror the endurance of a loving relationship – built to last while boasting brilliance and individuality. To buy diamonds as a gift is a way of acknowledging that love.

Whether it’s your first year or your fiftieth, diamond anniversary gifts remain the ultimate expression of love: timeless, meaningful and impossible to forget. 

Why natural diamonds are the best anniversary gift 

Admittedly, finding a gift as lasting as the love you’re celebrating is no easy task, but this is where natural diamonds come in.  

Thanks to their formation, natural diamonds embody a sense of permanence, timelessness and resilience in a way that no other gemstone can. In the same way a relationship naturally evolves over time, a diamond’s journey is one of similar transformation. 

To hand over such a gift not only honors the past you’ve shared together, but the future that’s still to come. It’s why, for generations, diamond jewelry has served as a universal gesture of devotion, love and respect – a reminder that, like a natural diamond, relationships can stand the test of time in a beautifully poignant way.  

The perfect diamond for every anniversary

Since every milestone deserves to be marked with a piece as rare and treasured as the love it celebrates, here are a few ideas on matching each chapter to a gemstone that feels completely personal and timeless. 

1st Anniversary gift: Marking the opening chapter of your story  

You’ve made it through your first year, congratulations! The first year is all about laying the foundation of your relationship together and figuring out the basics. Simple, but elegant pieces, like classic diamond stud earrings or a simple solitaire pendant would beautifully reflect this moment and serve as wardrobe essentials for years to come. Try thinking of this gift as the start of a beautiful jewelry collection that will grow over time.  

A natural diamond stud earring

5th Anniversary gift: Celebrating growth and shared memories 

The fifth year is all about appreciating how far you’ve come. By this point in a relationship, you’ve built your own new world together – full of joy, laughter and perhaps some more poignant times, too. Finding a design that reflects that period of growth and change – like a diamond station necklace (a dainty style of necklace embellished with gemstones) or a delicate tennis bracelet – is a beautiful way of capturing the idea of building something as a duo, that you can carry with you in the years to come.  

A natural diamond tennis bracelet

10th Anniversary gift: A decade of love 

Ten years together marks a huge milestone. It’s a period of sparkling highs and challenges that have likely deepened your unique and unbreakable bond. While new pieces are always welcome, many find themselves upgrading existing pieces of jewelry or making additions (think: heartfelt engravings or changes to engagement rings).  

Another smart choice here could be something like a natural diamond eternity band, with its unbroken circle of gems, perfectly symbolizing a love without end. Or for a day-to-day essential, a beautiful diamond-accented watch could make a meaningful choice.  

A natural diamond eternity band

25th Anniversary gift: The silver jubilee of your love  

A quarter-century together is no small feat. As a pair, you’ve created a whole host of wonderfully cherished moments, and only the very best statement-making pieces feel right for this milestone.  

How about a natural diamond tennis necklace or a large solitaire ring, something that embodies the strength and brilliance of your bond? At twenty-five years, love deserves to be celebrated with grandeur – and serious volume – so don’t be afraid of a grand gesture (or two).  

A natural diamond tennis necklace

50th Anniversary gift: A golden celebration  

Half a century of love is the ultimate testament to devotion and resilience. While anything goes here for a wedding anniversary gift – and only you know each other best – there’s something fitting about heirloom-worthy designs (think: elaborate necklaces, rare fancy-cut diamonds and multi-stone rings) to help carry the weight of this golden chapter. This anniversary is all about finding a piece of jewelry that honors the journey you’ve shared as well as allowing it to become a treasure for the next generation (if you’d like to, that is). So have fun with it.

natural diamond pendant set in gold

Adding a personal touch to your anniversary gift

While a natural diamond is already teeming with timeless meaning and thought, it’s often the pieces created or gifted with personal significance that stand the test of time and really deliver.  

Here are a few ways to make your anniversary jewelry truly personal: 

  • Mix your metals or settings. Combine yellow, white, and rose gold, or add a hidden motif that nods to your wedding day or a shared memory. A discreet birthstone beside a natural diamond can be a subtle but meaningful touch. 
  • Consider engraving. It’s a simple way to add intimacy. Think initials, a special date, or the coordinates of a place that means something to you both. It’s a quiet reminder of where your story began. 
  • Create complementary pieces. Matching bands, pendants, or cufflinks are a beautiful way to symbolize unity while keeping your individual styles intact. They also make great diamond gifts for men. 
  • Explore bespoke or custom designs. A bespoke jewelry (opens in new window) design gives you complete creative freedom, from the cut and carat to the finer details that reflect your relationship. 

Whatever you choose, personalization transforms any natural diamond from a beautiful object into something emotional, unique, and lasting. When your love story is built into the design, it becomes a much-loved keepsake, to be treasured for years to come. 

Selecting the right diamond for your partner 

Choosing the right natural diamond jewelry is as much about personality as it is about style. Each diamond color and cut carries its own mood and is a reflection of the person wearing it. 

Here’s how to find the one that feels most like them: 

  • Distinctive and unconventional: For the creative or free-spirited, Sunset Brown Desert Diamonds (opens in new window) or fancy-colored natural diamonds in pink or yellow make powerful choices. These hues reflect individuality, confidence, and emotion. 
  • Bright and symbolic: White and colorless diamonds remain enduring icons of devotion and commitment. Their unmatched sparkle and resilience mirror the qualities of lasting love itself. 
A selection of pear-shaped natural Desert diamonds

When choosing a diamond, let its color, cut, and energy echo your partner’s essence. A well-chosen natural diamond doesn’t just complement their jewelry collection; it tells the world who they are and what your love represents. 

A natural diamond makes every anniversary unforgettable

Anniversaries are a recognition of time, effort, and everything you’ve built together. A natural diamond brings weight to that moment without words. It’s an anniversary gift that feels personal yet enduring, something to wear now and keep for the years still unfolding.