Answer
Key takeaways
What can a diamond tester actually tell you?
Diamond pen testers can show whether a gem is diamond materialor imitation. They can’t reliably distinguish natural diamonds from lab-grown diamonds, which takes specialized spectrometric instrumentation found in gemological laboratories. A positive reading from a diamond pen tester is a useful first to confirm what you bought, but establishing a diamond’s identity is a job for a lab.

A diamond pen tester can help identify a diamond from an imitation, but it cannot reliably determine whether a diamond is natural or laboratory-grown.
Diamond vs. simulant: what testers are built to detect
Most handheld pen testers measure how quickly heat travels through a gem. A warmed probe touches the surface and the device reads how fast the heat is transferred through the material. Because diamond is highly thermally conductive, it can eliminate a lot of stimulants that are’t as conductive, such as cubic zirconia. However, this method is not foolproof. Moissanite will test a diamond using a thermal tester because it also conducts heat well. More advanced testers may combine thermal and electrical conductivity measurements for greater accuracy, as diamond is electrically insulating, separating it from synthetic moissanite, which is conductive.
Where home testers reach their limit
A home pen-tester reads how a gem handles heat or electricity. It can’t read how the diamond was formed. Thermal testers, the most common type, report natural and lab-grown diamonds as diamond because their thermal behavior matches. Electrical testers can misread some HPHT lab-grown diamonds as moissanite, because of traces of boron in the material, which gives the diamond material electrically conductive properties .
A natural diamond forms deep in the earth under extreme heat and pressure, a process that leaves its own trace elements and growth patterns that can only be detected by trained gemologists with specialized equipment.
Where can you get a diamond independently tested?
A diamond can be independently tested by a gemological lab or through a qualified jeweler if they have the required equipment.

Gemological laboratories
Major gemological laboratories such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) and the International Gemological Institute (IGI) use specialized equipment to establish whether a diamond is natural or lab-grown. Their reports also record characteristics such as diamond clarity (opens in a new window) as part of the 4Cs of diamonds. A laboratory report documents the diamond’s identity and characteristics.
Testing a loose diamond vs. a mounted diamond
A setting can obscure or influence a diamond’s color and clarity grade and make an exact carat weight difficult to determine. GIA grades only loose diamonds for its Diamond Grading Report. IGI also reports on mounted diamonds without taking them out of the setting, grading as far as the mounting permits. If your diamond is already set, ask the lab what it can assess with the stone still in its setting.
Independent appraisers and jewelers
Qualified independent appraisers and jewelers can examine diamonds and documentation and advise whether further testing is necessary. Always ask what testing they offer and whether they can arrange independent laboratory verification if needed.
Checking your existing report number and inscription
If your diamond came with a grading report, cross-reference its details against the lab’s official records. GIA’s Report Check lets you verify the information online. Some diamonds carry microscopic laser inscriptions that can be examined under magnification and compared with the report number.
What if the result does not match the paperwork?
A discrepancy could involve the diamond’s natural or laboratory-grown origin, grading or report details. However, if your result doesn’t match the paperwork, don’t immediately assume the worst. Gather your purchase documents and testing results before taking the next step.

Go back to the retailer first
Contact the retailer and explain the discrepancy. Provide all the necessary documentation, then ask for a written explanation and what they can do to resolve the issue.
Get a second independent opinion
If the retailer cannot resolve your concerns, have the diamond examined by an independent gemological laboratory. A second professional assessment will inform your next steps.
Know your consumer protection rights
In the U.S., the FTC’s Jewelry Guides set standards for how diamond labeling is governed (opens in a new window), including clear disclosure when a diamond is lab-grown rather than natural. If independent testing shows that a diamond sold as natural is lab-grown, keep your receipt, grading report, retailer correspondence and test results. Your records will be important if you pursue a refund, dispute the purchase, or make a consumer complaint.
FAQs
Do diamond tester apps work?
Diamond tester apps and smartphone cameras cannot reliably confirm whether a diamond is natural or lab-grown. Identifying whether a diamond is natural (opens in a new window) requires specialized gemological equipment.
Is a diamond appraisal the same as a lab report?
No. A diamond appraisal estimates its monetary value. A lab report documents its identity and quality characteristics, including the 4Cs of diamonds (opens in a new window). If you want to verify whether a diamond is natural or lab-grown, professional labs like GIA provide testing services for definitive identification.
Should you get a diamond appraised after buying it?
Getting a diamond appraised after purchase can give you an estimated value and be useful for insurance purposes. However, an appraisal is not a substitute for diamond grading (opens in a new window) and laboratory testing if your goal is to confirm its natural or laboratory-grown origin and identity.
Sources
- GIA. Is There a Difference Between Natural and Laboratory-Grown Diamonds? https://www.gia.edu/gia-news-research/difference-between-natural-laboratory-grown-diamonds (opens in a new window) Accessed October 15, 2026
- TR. Diamond Tester vs Diamond Screening Device.
https://jtr.org/us/en/guides/diamond-tester-vs-diamond-screening-device (opens in a new window). Oct. 22, 2026. - IGI. Diamond Detection and Handheld Testers. https://www.igi.org/diamond-detection-and-handheld-testers/ (opens in a new window) Accessed October 15, 2026
- IGI. “Diamond Detection and Handheld Testers.”
https://www.igi.org/diamond-detection-and-handheld-testers/ (opens in a new window) Accessed October 22, 2026 - GIA. “Is There a Difference Between Natural and Laboratory-Grown Diamonds?” https://www.gia.edu/gia-news-research/difference-between-natural-laboratory-grown-diamonds (opens in a new window) Accessed October 22, 2026
- GIA. “Why does a diamond have to be loose for the Diamond Grading Report and Colored Diamond Grading Report?”
https://www.gia.edu/FAQ/gia-faq-analysis-grading-loose-diamond-grading-report (opens in a new window) Accessed October 22, 2026 - IGI. “Gemstone Identification Report For Authentic Verification.”
https://www.igi.org/reports/diamond-identification-reports/ (opens in a new window) Accessed October 22, 2026 - GIA. 10 Tips for Buying a Diamond Online. https://my.gia.edu/research-news-tips-buying-diamonds-online (opens in a new window) Accessed October 15, 2026
- FTC. In the Loupe: Advertising Diamond, Gemstones and Pearls. https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/loupe-advertising-diamond-gemstones-pearls (opens in a new window) Accessed October 15, 2026
- GIA. Is There a Difference Between Natural and Laboratory-Grown Diamonds? https://www.gia.edu/gia-news-research/difference-between-natural-laboratory-grown-diamonds (opens in a new window) Accessed October 15, 2026
- GIA. What is the difference between a Diamond Grading Report and an Appraisal? https://4cs.gia.edu/en-us/blog/what-is-the-difference-between-a-diamond-grading-report-and-an-appraisal/ (opens in a new window) Accessed October 15, 2026